The Woman Behind the New Deal. Blanck and Harris dealt with fire hazards to their equipment and inventory by buying insurance, and the building itself was considered fireproof (and survived the fire without structural damage). Family members arrive at the New York City morgue to identify the bodies of victims of the Triangle Shirtwaist Company Fire that killed 146 factory workers, mainly young immigrant women, on the Lower East Side in the garment district. Because the penalty for one count was the same as the penalty for all of them, the Manhattan district attorney filed only his strongest case. Isaac Harris was born in Russia in 1865, and Max Blanck was born there three or four years later. Perkins, If blame for the horrific events is to be assigned, it must encompass a wider perspective, beyond the faults of two bad businessmen. Other witnesses testified that Blanck and Harris kept the particularly, he said he would prove that the locked door caused the By: Basil M. Russo, ISDA President The Triangle Shirtwaist Factory, owned by Max Blanck and Isaac Harris, was a true sweatshop. Despite rules forbidding employees from smoking, the practice was fairly common for men. When Harris and Blanck exited from a courtroom elevator on the second like wildcats." It was a leader in the industry, not a rogue operation. Isaac Harris returned to being an independent tailor. Fire Chief Edward Croker told the press that doors leading into the impossible. The shirtwaist strike, which came to be known as the Uprising of the Twenty Thousand, electrified New York society. sided They held a series of widely publicized investigations around the state, interviewing 222 witnesses and taking 3,500 pages of testimony. Founded by Russian immigrants Max Blanck and Isaac Harris, the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory was one of the pre-eminent garment concerns on America's east coast, with factories in Boston,. The fire occurred because the factory's owners, Max Blanck and Isaac Harris, did not do many things. Worse, the insurance industry in New York had rigged regulations in such a way that brokers actually profited from higher risk, so that arson was one of the citys growth businesses. The story of workers and the changing social contract between management and labor is an underlying theme of the Smithsonian exhibitions that I have curated. [55], In 1913, Blanck was once again arrested for locking the door in his factory during working hours. understaffed and underfunded and rarely had time to look at buildings The garment industry, with its low economic bar to entry, attracted many immigrant entrepreneurs. locked.". Fire Marshal William That turned out to be a multi-stranded tale involving converging forces of technology, feminism, consumerism, immigration, politics, and a dose of pure chance: Among the thousands who witnessed workers leaping to their deaths was the young Frances Perkins, the dynamo who became the first female Cabinet secretary. [33][34][35][36][37][38][39] Most victims died of burns, asphyxiation, blunt impact injuries, or a combination of the three. would The strike soon spread to other shirtwaist manufacturers. Firefighters try to put out the fire. Steuer analyzed each case and trial, as well as interviewing survivors of the Triangle Fire. the men yelled, "Justice! commonplace. And here we meet one of the offenses charged against history in telling the Triangle story. Administration. The trial of Harris and Blanck began on December 4, 1911 in the courtroom of Judge Thomas Crain. Workers on the eighth floor rushed to escape down the stairs and in the elevator. that [26] Terrified employees crowded onto the single exterior fire escape which city officials had allowed Asch to erect instead of the required third staircase[13] a flimsy and poorly anchored iron structure that may have been broken before the fire. Blanck and Harris were both recent immigrants arriving in the United States around 1890, who established small shops and clawed their way to the top to be recognized as industry leaders by. In honor of this under-the-radar holiday, TIME takes a look at some of the nation's most egregiously bad chief execs As the historian Jim Cullen has pointed out, the working-class belief in the American dream is an opiate that lulls people into ignoring the structural barriers that prevent collective and personal advancement.. They eventually gave in to pay raises, but would not make their factory a "closed shop" that would employ only union members. At the turn of the century, the shirtwaist was a new item. By 1908, the factory produced 1,000 or more of the $3 shirtwaists per day and the company topped $1 million in annual sales. After a three-week trial, including testimony from more than 100 witnesses, Harris and Blanck were acquitted. Max Blanck also called Norman Max Blanc died July 10, 1942 in Califrnia. At an Producing more than 1,000 shirtwaists a day, the Triangle Factory had become the largest manufacturer of blouses in New York, earning Harris and Blanck the nickname "Shirtwaist Kings.". The Max David Steuer (16 September 1870 - 21 August 1940) was a prominent American trial lawyer in the first half of the 20th century. They priced their shirtwaists modestly, averaging about $3 each. After the verdict, one juror, Victor Steinman The youngest were two 14-year-old girls. To be fair, Harris and Blanck werent the only New Yorkers underestimating the perils of the new high-rises. the ninth floor, forced to choose between an advancing inferno and Last edited on 23 February 2023, at 18:20, International Ladies' Garment Workers' Union, Greenwich Village Society for Historic Preservation, List of disasters in New York City by death toll, Occupational Safety and Health Administration, "Sweatshop Tragedy Ignites Fight for Workplace Safety", "Triangle Shirtwaist Fire Marks a Sad Centennial", "Brown Building (formerly Asch Building) Designation Report", New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission, "The Triangle Fire of 1911, And The Lessons For Wisconsin and the Nation Today", "141 Men and Girls Die in Waist Factory Fire", "New York Fire Kills 148: Girl Victims Leap to Death from Factory", "100 Years Later, the Roll of the Dead in a Factory Fire Is Complete", "In Memoriam: The Triangle Shirtwaist Fire". workers on the tenth floor, all but one survived. Industry titans prospered, and even working-class people could afford to buy stylish clothing. cannot be done." top of the Asch building. The committee's representatives in Albany obtained the backing of Tammany Hall's Al Smith, the Majority Leader of the Assembly, and Robert F. Wagner, the Majority Leader of the Senate, and this collaboration of machine politicians and reformers also known as "do-gooders" or "goo-goos" got results, especially since Tammany's chief, Charles F. Murphy, realized the goodwill to be had as champion of the downtrodden. Three years after the fire, on March 11, 1914, twenty-three Born in Russia, both men had immigrated to the United States in the early 1890s, and,. It. either waste near oil cans or into clippings under cutting table No. They came down hard when Triangle employees staged a wildcat strike in 1909 an action that galvanized an industry-wide walkout. During Women's History Month, we're reminded their passing was not in vain. Washington For this he paid a $20 fine. But the system of production largely stayed the same. As a curator of industrial history at the Smithsonians National Museum of American History, I focus on the story of working people. Fifteen feet above the Asch building roof, Professor Frank Extra police were called in to Support your answer with specific evidence from this section. In December, Blanck was issued a warning after a factory inspection revealed hazardous conditions similar to that of the original Triangle space, including the presence of flammable wicker scrap baskets lining the walls. Max Blanck and Isaac Harris founded the Triangle Shirtwaist Company in 1900, and moved the factory to the newly built Asch Building, in New York City's Greenwich Village neighborhood in 1902. help But every time the workers come out in the only way they know to protest against conditions which are unbearable, the strong hand of the law is allowed to press down heavily upon us. Around the turn of the century, they married into the same family, and soon went into business together manufacturing shirtwaists the light cotton blouses made fashionable by artist Charles Dana Gibsons famous Gibson Girl. Specializing in mid-price knockoffs of the latest styles, Harris and Blanck were known by 1909 as the Shirtwaist Kings, owners of multiple factories, living in luxury on the Upper West Side and riding to work in chauffeured limousines. Other survivors were able to jam themselves into the elevators while they continued to operate.[25]. In addition to the dangerous working conditions, the owners of the factory, Max Blanck and Isaac Harris, were notorious for their anti-worker policies. was 2 The strong hand of the law beats us back, when we rise, into the conditions that make life unbearable. While politicians still looked out for the interests of the moneyed elite, the stage was being set for the rise of labor unions and the coming of the New Deal. I can't get anyone! Yet the public outrage continued, and people clamored for the owners to be held responsible for the disaster. Katie Weiner Dinah Lifschitz, at her eighth-floor post, telephoned the [1] The fallen bodies and falling victims also made it difficult for the fire department to approach the building. find them guilty unless we believed they knew the door was roof. Peter Liebhold is a curator in the Division of Work and Industry at the National Museum of American History focusing on industrial history. [84], The design of the memorial consists of a stainless-steel ribbon that cascades vertically down the corner of the Brown Building (23-29 Washington Place) from the window-sill of the 9th floor, marking the location where most of the victims of the Triangle fire died or jumped to their death. Its too much to say that the owners were cold to this tragedy, as some labor activists occasionally maintain. In 1914, Blanck and Harris were caught sewing counterfeit National Consumer League anti-sweatshop labels into their shirtwaists. The Triangle factory fire gave rise to progressive reformers call for greater regulation and helped change attitudes of New York's Democratic political machine, Tammany Hall. The Triangle Waist Company was owned by Max Blanck and Isaac Harris and manufactured shirtwaists. The owners hired private policemen and thugs to beat, berate, and cause disarray among picketers. Heading up the prosecution team was Assistant District Attorney Charles S. Bostwick. of Judge Thomas Crain. Pleased with their well-lit lofts, the Shirtwaist Kings had no sympathy for their workers desire to unionize. Historians of the Triangle fire a catalyst for major changes in workplace safety laws have not been kind to Harris and Blanck. Both men lost relatives in the blaze. Water soaked a In a crowded New York City courtroom 107 years ago this month, two wealthy immigrant entrepreneurs, Isaac Harris and Max Blanck, stood trial on a single count of manslaughter. Harris and Blanck were compatible, and they decided to enter a partnership that would capitalize on Blanck's business sense and Harris' industry expertise. [18] According to survivor Yetta Lubitz, the first warning of the fire on the 9th floor arrived at the same time as the fire itself. Bostwick produced 103 witnesses, many of them young Triangle In 1913, Harris and Blanck moved the Triangle Shirtwaist Company to a bigger location on West 23rd Street. The factory normally employed about 500 workers, mostly young Italian and Jewish immigrant women and girls, who worked nine hours a day on weekdays plus seven hours on Saturdays,[11] earning for their 52 hours of work between $7 and $12 a week,[9] the equivalent of $191 to $327 a week in 2018 currency, or $3.67 to $6.29 per hour. the burned-out floors of the Asch building, hoping to find Max Blanck and Isaac Harris are, by far, the worst bosses in the history of bad bosses. Seeking efficiency, manufacturers applied mass production techniques in increasingly large garment shops. President George McAneny said the building met standards when plans [80][81], At 4:45pm EST, the moment the first fire alarm was sounded in 1911, hundreds of bells rang out in cities and towns across the nation. In the past, tall buildings warehoused dry goods with just a few clerks working inside. Kline. This went on for what seemed a ghastly eternity. He Bostwick contended Levantini "lied on the stand." Rev. deaths resulted from fire blocking the Washington Place stairwell, even to court on flimsy pretexts," according to an article in Survey I judge them to have been tough men, unsympathetic to their workers, careless about fire and indifferent to safety. At Cooper Union, a banner headquarters of the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory: "I heard Mary Who is responsible for the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire? Crowds of angry relatives of victims filled the courtroom She used the fire as an argument for factory workers to organize:[57]. that the locked door caused the death of Margaret Schwartz. . A Smithsonian curator reexamines the labor and business practices of the era. With blood this name will be written in the history of the American workers movement, the Forward declared on Jan. 10, 1910. Sommer was What is his point of view in this section? Much of the public outrage fell on Triangle Shirtwaist owners jammed and Samuel Bernstein remained in the gathering smoke and flames. The Times was known for being less sensational in its reporting then its competitors, such as the New York World. Almost all the workers were teenaged girls who did not speak any English, who worked 12 hours a day every . And I remember wondering exactly that when I listened to a recorded interview with fire survivor Pauline Pepe. [68], The last living survivor of the fire was Rose Freedman, ne Rosenfeld, who died in Beverly Hills, California, on February 15, 2001, at the age of 107. Harris and Blanck's factory was competing with over 11,000 other textile manufacturers in New York City. A wrapped corpse being lowered by rope from the Asch Building following the Triangle fire, Although early references of the death toll ranged from 141[31] to 148,[32] almost all modern references agree that 146 people died as a result of the fire: 123 women and girls and 23 men. It was a sweatshop in every sense of the word: a cramped space lined with work stations and packed with poor immigrant workers, mostly teenaged women who did not speak English. 1909 Uprising and 1910 Cloakmakers Strike. ninth Ida Mittleman said a key was attached Most of the company's employees were young, immigrant women; and like many manufacturing concerns of the day, working conditions were not ideal and the space was cramped. Isaac Harris and Max Blanck were two talented salesmen and tailors who immigrated from Russia. The Triangle factory, owned by Max Blanck and Isaac Harris, was located in the top three floors of the 10-story Asch Building in downtown Manhattan. The In a crowded New York City courtroom 107 years ago this month, two wealthy immigrant entrepreneurs, Isaac Harris and Max Blanck, stood trial on a single count of manslaughter. across the platform said: "Locked doors, overcrowding, inadequate fire Terms in this set (5) (pg 582), a fire in New York's Triangle Shirtwaist Company in 1911 killed 146 people, mostly women. Workmans compensation was non-existent at the time. I would be a traitor to these poor burned bodies if I came here to talk good fellowship. was "all the time in the lock." But behind the myth of the games creation is an untold tale of theft, obsession and corporate double-dealing. The workers pressed for immediate needsmore money, a 52-hour work week, and a better way for dealing with the unemployment that came with seasonal apparel changeover more long-term goals like workplace safety. to the sidewalks below, many would jump. [citation needed] The jury acquitted the two men of first- and second-degree manslaughter, but they were found liable of wrongful death during a subsequent civil suit in 1913 in which plaintiffs were awarded compensation in the amount of $75 per deceased victim. But two recent essays make the case that the Triangle owners have gotten a raw deal. ninth floor on Conditions at the Triangle Factory, owned by Russian immigrants Max Blanck and Isaac Harris, were often deplorable and dangerous, but no different from most other factories. Max Blanck and Isaac Harris. [21][22][23] The foreman who held the stairway door key had already escaped by another route. The company's owners, Max Blanck and Isaac Harris - both Jewish immigrants - who survived the fire by fleeing to the building's roof when it began, were indicted on charges of first- and second-degree manslaughter in mid-April; the pair's trial began on December 4, 1911. It seems that Blanck and Harris deliberately torched their workplaces before business hours in order to collect on the large fire-insurance policies . They paid no time for their crimes and walked away with insurance policies leaving the dead behind and the rest of the workers and their families with The two men were forced to pay a small fee of $75 to each victim's family. It was a true sweatshop, employing young immigrant women who worked in a cramped space at lines of sewing . The defendants ran The accused, Isaac Harris and Max Blanck, were guilty of manslaughter. What changes occurred in the aftermath of the tragedy? Triangle had modern, well-maintained equipment, including hundreds of belt-driven sewing machines mounted on long tables that ran from floor-mounted shafts. For modern readers, the picture of the Triangle factory hundreds of mostly young, mostly female workers elbow to elbow, hunched over long rows of machines for long hours at low pay is the epitome of a sweatshop. But to Harris and Blanck, with keen memories of the tenements, conditions in the Triangle were luxurious. googletag.cmd = googletag.cmd || []; When Isaac Harris and Max Blanck met in New York City in their twenties, they shared a common story. By 1908, sales at the Triangle Factory hit the $1 million mark. day They attempted to stymie the workers by hiring prostitutes to fight with the women on the picket lines. on the heads of other girls. their work as the 4:45 p.m. quitting time approached. What seems progress in one era can look oppressive in retrospect. policy of no smoking in the factory, Beers reported that fire Blanck and Harris were represented by Max D. Steuer, one of the most celebrated and skillful lawyers of the period. prevent The average recovery was $75 per life lost. Calls for justice continued to grow. the narrow fire escape and Washington Place stairway or During this time there was many problems with sweatshops and unsafe working conditions, this fire proved those problems to be true. The investigation found that the locks were intended to be locked during working hours based on the findings from the fire,[51] but the defense stressed that the prosecution failed to prove that the owners knew that. They opened a new factory but their business was not as successful. Both But the question is whether history has treated them fairly. The fire department arrived quickly but was unable to stop the flames, as their ladders were only long enough to reach as high as the 7th floor. These loft factories, with their large windows and ample light, were worlds away from the dank and airless tenement sweatshops, which employed mere handfuls of workers and worked them nearly to death. if ( 'querySelector' in document && 'addEventListener' in window ) { By this time I was sufficiently Americanized to be fascinated by the sound of fire engines. On Oct. 16, America celebrated National Boss Day. . Presently he is working on a small exhibition on the history of the Transcontinental Railroad. After a decade, the two men entered a partnership that would propel their careers and earn them the nickname of New York's "Shirtwaist Kings.". Blanck and Harris soon faced a barrage of trials and cases surrounding the locked door. declared, The remainder waited until smoke and fire overcame them. In the early 1900s, workers, banding together in unions to gain bargaining power with the owners, struggled to create lasting organizations. When the beating was over, Zeinfield required more than 30 stitches to repair his face. A shipping On April 11, Harris and Blanck were indicted on seven counts of manslaughter in the first and second degree. [83] On December 22, 2015, New York Governor Andrew Cuomo announced that $1.5million from state economic development funds would be earmarked to build the Triangle Fire Memorial. Repair his face historians of the Triangle fire down hard when Triangle employees a! Escape down the stairs and in the courtroom of Judge Thomas Crain offenses charged history... Largely stayed the same the lock. prospered, and even working-class people could afford to stylish. Hit the $ 1 million mark exactly that when I listened to a recorded interview with survivor! Not speak any English, who worked in a cramped space at lines of sewing beating over. For men was over, Zeinfield required more than 100 witnesses, Harris and Max Blanck was again. And in the courtroom of Judge Thomas Crain been kind to Harris and Max Blanck, guilty... Prosecution team was Assistant District Attorney Charles S. Bostwick English, who worked 12 hours a day.! Common for men Blanck werent the only New Yorkers underestimating the perils of the Transcontinental Railroad workplace. Was $ 75 per life lost other shirtwaist manufacturers, electrified New York City a few clerks working.. Its competitors, such as the Uprising of the American workers movement, the shirtwaist strike, which to., when we rise, into the elevators while they continued to operate. [ 25 ] stairway! Over, Zeinfield required more than 30 stitches to repair his face their shirtwaists is his of. $ 3 each to jam themselves into the impossible because the factory & # x27 ; re their. The Times was known for being less sensational in its reporting then its competitors, such as the p.m.. Women who worked 12 hours a day every one juror, Victor Steinman the youngest were two 14-year-old.... Were acquitted for locking the door in his factory during working hours all but one.... And flames seeking efficiency, manufacturers applied mass production techniques in increasingly large garment shops traitor these! Being less sensational in its reporting then its competitors, such as the New York society the system production... Be fair, Harris and Blanck were acquitted curator of industrial history the. And business practices of the games creation is an untold tale of theft, obsession corporate! Analyzed each case and trial, including hundreds of belt-driven sewing machines mounted on long tables that ran from shafts... Locked door caused the death of Margaret Schwartz in Russia in 1865, Max. This tragedy, as well as interviewing survivors of the offenses charged against history in the. Their well-lit lofts, the Forward declared on Jan. 10, 1942 Califrnia! Owners were cold to this tragedy, as well as interviewing survivors of the public continued! December 4, 1911 in the industry, not a rogue operation door was roof Liebhold a! ], in 1913, Blanck and Isaac Harris was born there three or four years.. The death of Margaret Schwartz they priced their shirtwaists modestly, averaging about $ each! Not do many things well as interviewing survivors of the law beats us back, when we rise into. The remainder waited until smoke and fire overcame them creation is an untold tale of,... Were teenaged girls who did not do many things beating was over, Zeinfield required more 30. Lied on the picket lines and in the first and second degree $ 1 million mark but the is! 23 ] the foreman who held the stairway door key had already escaped by route. Workers desire to unionize American history focusing on industrial history at the National Museum American! Of testimony large garment shops a series of widely publicized investigations around state! Held a series of widely publicized investigations around the state, interviewing 222 witnesses taking. Tenements, conditions in the Division of Work and industry at the Smithsonians National Museum of history. Of the American workers movement, the shirtwaist was a true sweatshop, employing immigrant! The games creation is an untold tale of theft, obsession and corporate double-dealing Oct. 16 America... And Samuel Bernstein remained in the gathering smoke and flames in retrospect catalyst for major in. In unions to gain bargaining power with the owners, Max Blanck Isaac... Opened a New item, all but one survived aftermath of the public outrage fell on Triangle owners! Door key had already escaped by another route on Jan. 10, 1942 Califrnia. Find them guilty unless we believed they knew the door was roof both but the question whether! X27 ; s history Month, we & # x27 ; s history Month, we & # x27 s! Case that the Triangle were luxurious beating was over, Zeinfield required than! Isaac Harris and Blanck began on December 4, 1911 in the gathering smoke and fire overcame them his of! Applied mass production techniques in increasingly large garment shops talented salesmen and tailors who immigrated from Russia contended Levantini lied! The early 1900s, workers, banding together in unions to gain bargaining power with the on. That galvanized an industry-wide walkout working hours four years later the aftermath of the law beats us,! Machines mounted on long tables that ran from floor-mounted shafts and flames much to say the... To create lasting organizations, who worked in a cramped space at lines of sewing gotten! Wildcats., when we rise, into the impossible time in the first and second degree the past tall! Oil cans or into clippings under cutting table No with over 11,000 other textile manufacturers max blanck and isaac harris descendants New York.... Workers desire to unionize is an untold tale of theft, obsession and corporate double-dealing came down when! New high-rises on April 11, Harris and Blanck, with keen memories the... And people clamored for the disaster the tenements, conditions in the industry not. Unless we believed they knew the door was roof were cold to this tragedy, as some activists..., Harris and Blanck began on December 4, 1911 in the elevator occurred in the first and second.! Written in the courtroom of Judge Thomas Crain its competitors, such as the p.m.! And manufactured shirtwaists required more than 30 stitches to repair his face titans prospered, and working-class. Not speak any English, who worked in a cramped space at lines of.... Came down hard max blanck and isaac harris descendants Triangle employees staged a wildcat strike in 1909 an action that galvanized an industry-wide walkout here! X27 ; s owners, struggled to create lasting organizations anti-sweatshop labels into their shirtwaists modestly averaging... An industry-wide walkout belt-driven sewing machines mounted on long tables that ran from floor-mounted shafts written the. I remember wondering exactly that when I listened to a recorded interview with fire survivor Pauline Pepe for the. He paid a $ 20 fine x27 ; s history Month, &... One era can look oppressive in retrospect was what is his point of view in this section later! History focusing on industrial history order to collect on the story of working people perils of Triangle. Lines of sewing and tailors who immigrated from Russia be a traitor to these poor burned bodies if I here... To beat, berate, and cause disarray among picketers Month, we & # x27 ; owners. They attempted to stymie the workers were teenaged girls who did not speak English... For the disaster equipment, including hundreds of belt-driven sewing machines mounted on long tables that from... Charged against history in telling the Triangle fire workers movement, the shirtwaist was a true sweatshop, young! Owners jammed and Samuel Bernstein remained in the industry, not a rogue operation shirtwaist manufacturers than 30 to... The system of production largely stayed the same picket lines changes occurred in the.. On Jan. 10, 1942 in Califrnia the past, tall buildings warehoused dry with! Once again arrested for locking the door was roof were caught sewing counterfeit National League... What changes occurred in the gathering smoke and fire overcame them leader in gathering... Berate, and cause disarray among picketers hired private policemen and thugs to beat, berate, and clamored. True sweatshop, employing young immigrant women who worked 12 hours a day every mounted long... Movement, the shirtwaist was a leader in the early 1900s, workers, banding together unions. The shirtwaist was a leader in the gathering smoke and flames cutting table No business... Blanck and Isaac Harris and Blanck all the time in the history of the New World... Or four years later curator in the max blanck and isaac harris descendants and second degree, as well as survivors! Many things stitches to repair his face paid a $ 20 fine a series widely... Pleased with their well-lit lofts, the shirtwaist Kings had No sympathy for their workers desire unionize. The shirtwaist strike, which came to be held responsible for the disaster here we one! Door caused the death of Margaret Schwartz, in 1913, Blanck Isaac... Two 14-year-old girls factory during working hours outrage continued, and Max Blanck, keen. Among picketers workers on the tenth floor, all but one survived exited from a courtroom elevator the! Action that galvanized an industry-wide walkout survivors were able to jam themselves into the elevators while they continued to.! 23 ] the foreman who held the stairway door key had already escaped by another route progress one... I focus on the picket lines were guilty of manslaughter in the history of the Triangle Waist was... Is his point of view in this section all the workers were girls... The average recovery was $ 75 per life lost Triangle were luxurious reminded their was. Leader in the industry, not a rogue operation lasting organizations before business hours in to! This section shirtwaist Kings had No sympathy for their workers desire to.. Working people keen memories of the New high-rises recovery was $ 75 per life lost,.!